Slug & Lede

News, Features & Multimedia Critiques from UI J-school students

Video Critique

with 2 comments

I thought that Pawel Dwulit’s video about the 80 cats being given away for adoption by a a man named Frank Currell in Scarboro was interesting, to say the least. I was a little shocked at first by the mere idea that an owner could own that many animals in one place, and was even more surprised to see through the video that the animals and home seemed to be in very good shape.

We’ve all read and seen videos and news stories about the horrors of homes with 100 dogs or 50 cats, and in a way, I suppose this video was able to give a face to the names of all the people we read about that hoard animals.

Though I thought that the story within itself was interesting, I was quite disappointed by the lack of context provided to the viewer during the progression of the piece. Why did Currell and his wife have so many cats? How did they manage to take care of them all? Do the pets have names? Have they ever faced ridicule or problems for having so many pets? I just felt that there were far too many unanswered questions left for the viewer to speculate answers for. 

I thought that the dialogue given by Currell was very good, I just think that Pawel Dwulit should have expanded upon the story of the man and his wife to clarify what happened to her, and how his having cancer has affected the lives of the animals.

Written by erica-pennington

March 28th, 2009 at 3:53 pm

2 Responses to 'Video Critique'

Subscribe to comments with RSS or TrackBack to 'Video Critique'.

  1. I agree with you that there were numerous questions that if answered would have made the video much better. As you mentioned, the big one being; why exactly did they have so many cats? And then another that I wondered was why cats? What about that animal appealed to them so much so that they would keep 80 to 100? I feel like Dwulit did not really elaborate on the topic as much as he could have leaving the piece a bit dry.

    cdmills

    1 Apr 09 at 3:58 pm

  2. Although these questions do go unanswered, I don’t feel like they are really necessary information to be able to understand what is going on in the video. I also thought that while the dialogue was good, there could’ve been more of a variety of shots in the video.

    kaoneill

    1 Apr 09 at 9:38 pm

Leave a Reply